← All writing

Community philanthropy · 2025 · 5 min

Participation only counts when it moves a decision

A working test for participatory processes: name the decision that would have gone differently.

There is a simple test I apply to any process that calls itself participatory. Name the decision that went differently because people participated. If no such decision exists, the process was consultation, and consultation that changes nothing costs communities time they do not have.

Placeholder: expand with concrete examples from participatory grantmaking work — decision rules, budget authority, committee composition, compensation.

The design question is therefore not how to gather more input. It is which decisions are genuinely open, who should hold them, and what the institution is prepared to lose control of.

Draft written from your positioning notes — review and replace with your own text or a link to the published version.

Have a complex challenge worth working on?

If you are facing something you cannot yet name a solution for, that is usually the right moment to talk.